Can an attorney successfully represent a client but still commit legal malpractice?

Legal malpractice can occur even when the attorney has successfully represented a client.   This occurred in Bijou v. Young-Battle 185 Md.App. 268 (2009).    Andrienne Young-Battle was bitten on the hand by a dog owned by Leila Bijou.  Young-Battle retained counsel and sued Young-Battle for $250,000.   The jury returned a verdict in the amount of $504,480, including $311,000 in loss earnings as a graphic designer.    At this point, Young-Battle’s attorney should have requested that the Court amend her $250,000 damage demand to conform with the $504,480 verdict.   But he didn’t.   The result was that the Court reduced the $504,480 judgment to $250,000.   The attorney’s malpractice cost the client $254,480. 

Queries:  Do you think that Young-Battle’s attorney was entitled to receive one-third of the reduced $250,000 verdict?   If Young-Battle’s attorney had malpractice insurance that covered the $254,480 in damages, was the attorney entitled to receive one-third of $504,480 as fees?

Comments are closed.

Articles
Article by Stewart A. Sutton featured in the Maryland Bar Journal:
Emotional Distress Damages - Recoverable in Legal Malpractice Actions
Contact Stewart Sutton

Receive Complimentary Case Consultation

To contact us simply complete this form or contact us using the information provided below.

[contact-form 404 "Not Found"]

Law Office of Stewart Andrew Sutton, LLC
8 Executive Park Court
Germantown, Maryland 20874
Telephone: 301-916-5000
Fax: 301-916-1201
E-Mail: stewart@stewartsutton.com

  • Insurer v. Defense Attorney in Legal Malpractice September 3, 2010
    It's not often that one sees an insurer v. defense attorney legal malpractice case, but this one seems to have very big damages. […]
  • Pa. Jury Awards $1.8 Million in Legal Malpractice Suit September 3, 2010
    A Philadelphia jury has awarded nearly $1.8 million in a legal malpractice case in which the plaintiff alleged her attorney failed to plead all of the relevant theories in her medical malpractice case, leading to the necessity of settling her case for $1 million, despite having received a $2.5 million verdict. […]
  • The Defense of Legal Malpractice Cases - Including Your Own September 2, 2010
    The story you have requested is available only to premium access subscribers. Premium subscribers have access to every news story, decision and special report we publish, including a complete one-year searchable archive and exclusive e-mail news alerts. […]
  • Motions to Dismiss and Legal Malpractice September 2, 2010
    The relationship between a motion to dismiss [CPLR 3211]. a request to amend the pleadings, and dismissal on the merits is wrought with both emotion yet is based upon logic. […]
  • Michigan Medical and Legal Professionals Turn to Geoffrey Brown for Malpractice Appeals September 2, 2010
    As a distinguished member of Michigan law firm Collins, Einhorn, Farrell & Ulanoff, P.C., Geoffrey Brown focuses primarily on defense of medical and legal malpractice at the appellate level. […]